Marc Goldwein, senior vice president and senior policy director at the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, has a knack for making universal healthcare sound like a math problem. Which, to be fair, it kind of is. In a series of replies on X on Monday, Goldwein walked through the financing of Medicare for All, explaining why his earlier 32% payroll-tax estimate might now land in the mid-20s, and why the real number could still creep into the "high 20s at least."
The discussion centered on a simple question: would Medicare for All save the average American money by swapping private insurance premiums and out-of-pocket costs for taxes? The answer, as you might expect, depends on who you are and how you count.
Who Receives More Than They Pay
"The math isn’t that difficult," Goldwein wrote, estimating that approximately 75% of people would receive healthcare benefits worth more than their payroll-tax contributions. That sounds like a pretty good deal for most people, until you remember that the remaining 25% are the ones writing the bigger checks.
He noted that a much smaller percentage would actually "pay less" because some benefits would come through additional healthcare services and most people have below-average cost-sharing expenses in a given year. In other words, the average person doesn't spend a ton on healthcare in any given year, so replacing premiums with a flat tax can feel like a wash or worse for some.
Goldwein also questioned the economic consequences of replacing all insurance premiums and cost-sharing expenses with a 32% payroll tax, saying the impact could be significantly negative and reduce incomes. That's the thing about big taxes: they tend to change behavior.
Asked where the 32% figure came from, Goldwein said it was based on an analysis conducted in 2020, when a payroll tax of approximately that size would have been needed to finance an estimated $30 trillion in Medicare for All costs over a decade. Since then, the payroll base has grown and estimates of the program's cost may have declined in inflation-adjusted terms. He hasn't updated the full analysis, but he said he could imagine the required rate being in the mid-20s.
Updated Payroll-Tax Calculations
In another reply, Goldwein offered some preliminary math. Citing a Congressional Budget Office estimate, he said a 2% payroll tax could raise $2.5 trillion over 10 years, or $2.7 trillion over the current budget window. Without employer-sponsored insurance, that amount could reach $2.9 trillion.
Scale that up, and a 20% payroll tax could raise $29 trillion. But here's where it gets tricky: Goldwein estimated that increasing the employer payroll-tax rate to 10% could reduce income and other tax revenue by approximately one-third, pushing the required rate to 24%. That's the feedback loop that makes static scoring look optimistic.
Goldwein's Earlier Cost Estimate
Goldwein had previously estimated that Medicare for All could cost the federal government between $20 trillion and $40 trillion over a decade, depending on the program's design. He also said prescription drug reform could save several hundred billion dollars independently, or as much as $3 trillion in the context of Medicare for All.
The financing debate has also featured questions about tax increases as Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) renewed his push for the program, including a proposal to lower Medicare eligibility to 55, cover children and expand dental, vision and hearing coverage.
Goldwein said the more people and businesses try to avoid higher taxes as rates increase, the more the required payroll-tax rate could rise. "I can’t estimate the impact on Twitter, but it’s likely to push you in the high 20s at least," he wrote.
So there you have it: the math isn't that difficult, but the politics and the behavioral economics are. And if you're wondering whether Medicare for All would save you money, the answer is a solid maybe, depending on your income, your healthcare usage, and how good you are at avoiding taxes.