Shares of Netflix Inc. (NFLX) jumped nearly 9% in overnight trading on Thursday. The reason? The streaming giant officially decided not to get into a bidding war for Warner Bros. Discovery (WBD). Sometimes the best deal is the one you walk away from, and the market seems to agree.

Prominent investor Gary Black, Managing Partner of The Future Fund, was quick to praise the retreat. He called it the "best move for $NFLX shareholders." The logic is pretty straightforward: avoiding a costly acquisition battle preserves Netflix's balance sheet and lets the company stick to its own strategic game plan without the distraction and financial strain of a massive merger.

The market is now looking for the stock to recover its recent losses. Before Netflix made its initial bid for WBD back on December 5th, the stock was trading near $100. After closing at $84.59 on Thursday, the shift in focus back to Netflix's core business represents a significant opportunity, according to Black.

"We believe… NFLX stock can return to the ~$100/share level," Black noted. That's an 18% upside from Thursday's close. Investors wasted no time, sending shares up to $92.77 in extended trading as they embraced Netflix's show of financial discipline.

The $2.8 Billion Silver Lining

So, why did Netflix walk away? It all came down to price. The WBD board labeled a rival bid from Paramount Skydance Corp. (PSKY) as a "superior proposal." In a joint statement, Netflix co-CEOs Ted Sarandos and Greg Peters clarified that while the merger was a "nice to have" at their original price, matching the higher offer was no longer "financially attractive."

Here's where it gets interesting. Netflix's exit comes with a massive consolation prize. Because Netflix had a signed agreement for WBD's streaming business at $27.75 per share, WBD's acceptance of the $31 per share Skydance deal triggers a termination fee payable to Netflix.

"NFLX should still get its $2.8B termination fee since it simply declined to raise its offer," Black explained.

That's not just a fee; it's a potential war chest. Black suggested this capital could be immediately put to work on high-value content. He even speculated on a potential new frontier for the streamer: "NFL Saturday night football anyone?" A $2.8 billion windfall certainly opens up some interesting possibilities.

Context and Performance

The positive reaction to this news comes against a backdrop of recent underperformance for Netflix stock. Year-to-date, shares of NFLX have fallen by 9.78%, while the Nasdaq 100 index has declined by a much smaller 0.68%. Over the last six months, the stock is down 31.01%, and it's off 14.56% over the past year.

On Thursday, the stock closed 2.28% higher at $84.59 before rocketing up another 9.09% in after-hours trading on the merger news. Market data indicates that NFLX has maintained a weak price trend over the short, medium, and long terms, alongside a solid quality ranking.