Casey's General Stores, Inc. (CASY) is gearing up to report second-quarter earnings after the market closes on Tuesday, December 9, and analysts are expecting some solid numbers from the convenience store chain.

The consensus view has the Ankeny, Iowa-based company delivering earnings of $5.20 per share, which would represent a decent uptick from the $4.85 per share it posted in the same quarter last year. Revenue expectations are even more impressive—analysts are looking for $4.5 billion compared to $3.95 billion a year earlier, according to market data.

Casey's has recent momentum on its side. Back on September 8, the company reported first-quarter earnings of $5.77 per share, sailing past the Street estimate of $5.07 per share. Quarterly revenue came in at $4.56 billion, also beating the consensus of $4.47 billion. That kind of performance tends to get Wall Street's attention.

Casey's shares dipped slightly on Monday, falling 0.1% to close at $566.52.

What makes this earnings release particularly interesting is what some of the most accurate analysts covering the stock have been saying lately. Here's a rundown of recent analyst activity from forecasters with solid track records:

• Stephens & Co. analyst Pooran Sharma maintained an Overweight rating and raised the price target from $570 to $600 on December 3, 2025. This analyst has an accuracy rate of 69%.
• Wells Fargo analyst Edward Kelly maintained an Overweight rating and boosted the price target from $610 to $625 on December 2, 2025. This analyst has an accuracy rate of 65%.
• Goldman Sachs analyst Bonnie Herzog maintained a Neutral rating and boosted the price target from $450 to $490 on September 10, 2025. This analyst has an accuracy rate of 66%.
• Wells Fargo analyst Anthony Bonadio maintained an Overweight rating and raised the price target from $540 to $580 on September 10, 2025. This analyst has an accuracy rate of 70%.
• BMO Capital analyst Kelly Bania maintained a Market Perform rating and raised the price target from $515 to $540 on September 10, 2025. This analyst has an accuracy rate of 68%.

The pattern here is pretty clear: even analysts who aren't wildly bullish are raising their targets. When multiple forecasters with proven accuracy rates start nudging their numbers higher, it's usually worth paying attention. The question now is whether Casey's can deliver another beat when it reports on Tuesday.