Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-La.) spent part of his Sunday morning on CBS News' Face The Nation making the case that Congress can fix Social Security without raising taxes, and he thinks he has the votes to prove it.
Cassidy told host Margaret Brennan that his proposed $1.5 trillion investment fund could cover up to 70% of Social Security's funding needs, while warning that congressional inaction is putting the program's future at risk.
The $1.5 Trillion Idea
The mechanics are straightforward enough. Cassidy's proposal would borrow $1.5 trillion, place it in an investment fund kept separate from the Social Security Trust Fund, and invest it in the broader economy over six decades. He said the fund could eventually pay for up to 70% of what is needed to cover Social Security's debt.
He first outlined the plan in October, describing a contribution schedule of $1.5 trillion over five years, or $250 billion annually. At the time, he said the fund could cover 60% to 70% of Social Security's unfunded accrued liability over 65 to 75 years. He also warned that benefits could face a 28.5% cut if Congress did not act.
On Sunday, Cassidy said he had commitments from Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) and Sen. Mike Crapo (R-Idaho) to hold a hearing and markup on a Social Security bill. He also said President Donald Trump had personally committed to supporting the legislation.
"I have Democrats who are also supportive. It's a bipartisan bill," Cassidy said.
Not everyone is on board, apparently. Cassidy said Senate Finance Committee ranking member Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) "does not want to be constructive." He added that while Wyden opposed investing taxpayer money in the stock market, he had previously backed a similar policy for the federal railroad retirement system under President George W. Bush.
Cassidy said the legislation could receive 60 Senate votes, pass the House and be signed by the president. He added that Congress should act now because "Social Security has been looking ill for some time."
The Math Is Not Great
The urgency is not hard to understand. Social Security faces projected shortfalls, and there is limited appetite in Washington for near-term tax increases.
In a November report, Jessica Riedl, a fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, said payroll tax increases were unlikely in the near term. The report also noted that the retirement trust fund was projected to run out in 2032, potentially triggering a 22% reduction in benefits.
A separate November report citing an AARP Public Policy Institute analysis found that Social Security's costs exceeded its revenue by $160 billion, or 11%, in 2025. That analysis projected the combined retirement and disability trust funds would be depleted in 2034, after which Social Security would have enough revenue to pay about 83% of scheduled benefits.
So the choice, roughly speaking, is between doing something now or explaining to voters later why their checks got smaller.
Cassidy Also Has Thoughts On Healthcare
The senator did not limit his criticism to Social Security. He also went after rising healthcare expenses, saying costs were "sky-high" and continuing to increase, while small businesses were dropping health coverage and employees were struggling to afford their deductibles.
He described the situation as a failure and called for accountability over rising costs.
Cassidy tied those concerns to his broader criticism of Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., saying there had been minimal progress on addressing ultra-processed foods. At the same time, he said, the country had lost its measles elimination status and infants were dying from measles.
"If I were president, I would choose someone else because there needs to be accountability for higher healthcare costs, more measles deaths, losing elimination status, and no progress on processed foods," Cassidy stated.
Whether any of this turns into legislation is another matter. But Cassidy is at least making the argument that the alternative to his $1.5 trillion fund is a benefit cut that voters will notice.