The Market's 2022 Flashback: When Energy Wins, Everything Else Loses
MarketDash
The equal-weight S&P 500 is having its worst month since 2022, with every sector except energy in the red. It's a familiar, painful script for investors.
Get APA Alerts
Weekly insights + SMS alerts
Here’s a simple, brutal rule of thumb for the stock market right now: if it’s not energy, it’s probably down. Way down.
Take a look at the S&P 500 this month. It’s a sea of red across nearly every sector you can name—technology, healthcare, industrials, you name it. There’s exactly one green island in that sea: the energy sector. It’s a scene that should feel eerily familiar to anyone who invested through 2022.
Back then, it was Russia’s invasion of Ukraine that broke the market’s back. An energy shock sent oil prices soaring, inflation surged, and the Federal Reserve embarked on its most aggressive hiking cycle in decades. The lesson was harsh but clear: when energy wins, everything else tends to lose.
Fast forward to today. Over the last 21 days, conflict involving Iran has effectively hit the rewind button, reproducing every key ingredient from that 2022 playbook. Oil spiking above $100 a barrel? Check. Odds of future Fed rate hikes surging? Check. And the same brutal lesson is now visible in the charts all over again.
The Breadth Signal That Should Worry Every Investor
To understand where the market actually stands, you can’t just look at the headline S&P 500 index. That cap-weighted version is dominated by a handful of mega-cap tech stocks, whose performance can mask the ugly decline happening underneath the surface.
The real story is in the equal-weight version, where every company in the index counts the same. That’s tracked by the Invesco S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF (RSP), and it’s down 7% month-to-date through March 20. That’s its worst monthly performance since September 2022.
Let that sink in. When the RSP falls 7%, it means the average S&P 500 stock has lost nearly 7% of its value this month. September 2022 was the month the Fed raised rates by 75 basis points for the third consecutive time and signaled it would keep tightening until inflation was broken. The market is flashing a signal it hasn’t used in over a year and a half.
This Is The 2022 Script, Playing Out Again
The anatomy of both market episodes is identical. It starts with an energy supply shock that investors try to dismiss as temporary. Then comes an inflation print that proves them wrong. Finally, the Federal Reserve finds itself caught between its mandate to fight inflation and a slowing economy.
In 2022, the S&P 500—as tracked by the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY)—fell 19.4% for the year as the Fed’s tightening crushed equity valuations. The hardest-hit sectors were the most sensitive to interest rates: technology, real estate, and consumer discretionary.
The only winner that year, just like now, was energy. The rotation signal that paid off back then is flashing bright red again today.
The S&P 500 Sector Scorecard: One Winner, Ten Losers
The month-to-date sector performance tells the whole story of this divergence. Here’s how the major sector ETFs have fared through March 20:
That’s a 14-percentage-point gap between the energy sector and the average S&P 500 stock—the widest performance spread since January 2022.
The 10 Oil Stocks Thriving Amid the Turmoil
Inside the energy sector’s 7% monthly gain, the rally has been led by specific names. Ten oil and gas stocks have posted double-digit returns since the conflict began.
APA Corporation (APA) leads the pack with a stunning 28.41% return. But look who’s right behind it: refiners. Marathon Petroleum (MPC) and Valero Energy (VLO) are up 18.55% and 18.36%, respectively. They’re capturing the widening spread between the cost of crude oil they buy and the price of refined products like diesel and gasoline they sell, with retail diesel approaching $5.10 nationally and gasoline nearing the $4 mark.
This is significant. In early 2022, refiners initially lagged behind oil producers as investors hoped for a quick resolution to the crisis. This time, the refiner rally is happening at the same time as the surge in upstream producers. It’s a signal that the market isn’t betting on a short-lived disruption. It’s pricing in something deeper and longer from the very start.
So, the market’s memory is long, and it’s playing a hit from 2022 on repeat. When energy prices spike on geopolitical fear, the old rules come back into force. For now, the rule is simple: energy wins, everything else pays the price.