Marketdash

Why The S&P 500 Isn't Panicking Yet, According To iCapital's Strategist

MarketDash
Despite surging oil prices and escalating conflict with Iran, iCapital's Sonali Basak points to a simple technical level that suggests the market is still far from throwing in the towel.

Get Market Alerts

Weekly insights + SMS alerts

It's a Monday morning with oil prices spiking, a war escalating, and headlines screaming about market panic. So naturally, Sonali Basak, Chief Investment Strategist at iCapital, decided to post a calm, data-driven check on X.

"The S&P 500 is less than 5% off its intraday heights, and >150 points above its 200-day moving average," Basak wrote. "We are far from capitulation."

Think about that for a second. With all the chaos, the benchmark index is still chilling comfortably above a key technical line that institutional traders watch like hawks. The index, as tracked by the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY), was trading around 6,697.79 on Monday, down about 0.63%. The Invesco QQQ Trust (QQQ), which tracks the Nasdaq-100, was down a milder 0.33%.

Basak isn't ignoring the mood. She gets it. "There's a lot of challenging sentiment out there, because there's a lot of uncertainty," she said. "The environment could change in any direction, honestly."

But she's making a classic trader's move: separating sentiment from structure. The scary headlines are one thing; the actual price level of the market is another. And right now, the structure—that distance from the 200-day average—is telling a less panicked story.

Of course, the pressure is real. Monday saw crude oil surge, complicating the picture for everyone. Both WTI and Brent held above $100 a barrel, and prices had briefly spiked near $120 earlier in the session according to market data. The surge came after major Middle Eastern producers cut output, with the critical Strait of Hormuz shut amid the ongoing conflict.

The United States Oil Fund (USO) shot up over 5%. Crude has jumped roughly 50% since U.S.-Israel strikes on Iran began back on February 28. That's not nothing.

The geopolitical backdrop driving all this showed no signs of cooling off either. Mojtaba Khamenei, son of the late Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, was named Iran's new Supreme Leader after his father was killed, according to state media. In a characteristically direct statement, former President Donald Trump said Monday that Mojtaba would need U.S. approval to remain in power.

Meanwhile, the physical risks to energy infrastructure continued. Bahrain's Bapco Energies declared force majeure after an Iranian drone struck its Sitra refinery. Saudi Arabia's military intercepted a drone near the Shaybah Oilfield.

The response from major economies is starting to take shape. Reports indicate G7 finance ministers are set to discuss a coordinated release from emergency oil reserves through the International Energy Agency.

So you have rising oil prices, escalating war, and attacks on refineries. The sentiment is, understandably, tense. But Basak's point is worth considering: sometimes the market's technical posture tells you more about its true resilience than the day's frightening headlines do. The 200-day moving average isn't a magic line, but breaking far below it is often a signal of genuine, widespread panic—the kind of "capitulation" traders talk about. For now, despite everything, the market isn't there yet.

Why The S&P 500 Isn't Panicking Yet, According To iCapital's Strategist

MarketDash
Despite surging oil prices and escalating conflict with Iran, iCapital's Sonali Basak points to a simple technical level that suggests the market is still far from throwing in the towel.

Get Market Alerts

Weekly insights + SMS alerts

It's a Monday morning with oil prices spiking, a war escalating, and headlines screaming about market panic. So naturally, Sonali Basak, Chief Investment Strategist at iCapital, decided to post a calm, data-driven check on X.

"The S&P 500 is less than 5% off its intraday heights, and >150 points above its 200-day moving average," Basak wrote. "We are far from capitulation."

Think about that for a second. With all the chaos, the benchmark index is still chilling comfortably above a key technical line that institutional traders watch like hawks. The index, as tracked by the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY), was trading around 6,697.79 on Monday, down about 0.63%. The Invesco QQQ Trust (QQQ), which tracks the Nasdaq-100, was down a milder 0.33%.

Basak isn't ignoring the mood. She gets it. "There's a lot of challenging sentiment out there, because there's a lot of uncertainty," she said. "The environment could change in any direction, honestly."

But she's making a classic trader's move: separating sentiment from structure. The scary headlines are one thing; the actual price level of the market is another. And right now, the structure—that distance from the 200-day average—is telling a less panicked story.

Of course, the pressure is real. Monday saw crude oil surge, complicating the picture for everyone. Both WTI and Brent held above $100 a barrel, and prices had briefly spiked near $120 earlier in the session according to market data. The surge came after major Middle Eastern producers cut output, with the critical Strait of Hormuz shut amid the ongoing conflict.

The United States Oil Fund (USO) shot up over 5%. Crude has jumped roughly 50% since U.S.-Israel strikes on Iran began back on February 28. That's not nothing.

The geopolitical backdrop driving all this showed no signs of cooling off either. Mojtaba Khamenei, son of the late Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, was named Iran's new Supreme Leader after his father was killed, according to state media. In a characteristically direct statement, former President Donald Trump said Monday that Mojtaba would need U.S. approval to remain in power.

Meanwhile, the physical risks to energy infrastructure continued. Bahrain's Bapco Energies declared force majeure after an Iranian drone struck its Sitra refinery. Saudi Arabia's military intercepted a drone near the Shaybah Oilfield.

The response from major economies is starting to take shape. Reports indicate G7 finance ministers are set to discuss a coordinated release from emergency oil reserves through the International Energy Agency.

So you have rising oil prices, escalating war, and attacks on refineries. The sentiment is, understandably, tense. But Basak's point is worth considering: sometimes the market's technical posture tells you more about its true resilience than the day's frightening headlines do. The 200-day moving average isn't a magic line, but breaking far below it is often a signal of genuine, widespread panic—the kind of "capitulation" traders talk about. For now, despite everything, the market isn't there yet.